Super Bowl Sunday Is the Highest-Volume Day on Your Calendar — Your Staff Is Winging It

And here's the part that makes it worse. Super Bowl weekend is when every sports bar, wing spot, and neighborhood tavern calls in their part-timers. You've got people on the floor that Sunday who haven't worked a shift since mid-December. They don't know the new bucket deal you built for game day. They don't know that the "inferno" sauce on the wing menu is a different heat level than what you ran last season. They've never been asked a question about it, so they have no idea they don't know.

That knowledge gap is where your night falls apart.

Let me be specific about what goes wrong. A table of eight orders two shareable platters. One guest mentions she has a shellfish allergy. Your server, who's been on for six hours and is now running three tables deep during the third quarter, reassures her the wings are fine. What he doesn't know is that one of the game-day sauces has a secret ingredient that changed in January, or that the nacho platter comes out of a shared fryer. Nobody told him. Nobody asked him. He's guessing, and he sounds confident while he does it.

That's not a training failure at 4pm on Sunday. That's a training failure at 4pm on the Wednesday before.

The volume problem on Super Bowl Sunday is unforgiving because the service window is long. New Year's Eve, something goes sideways, you reset and recover. Super Bowl, you're in continuous service for eight or nine hours with no natural break. Table turns are constant from noon through halftime. The kitchen is maxed. Your bartenders are making the same five drinks on repeat. And the guests are loud, distracted, and not in the mood to wait while your server goes back to double-check on something.

The only staff who perform well in that environment are the ones who already have the information loaded. They don't have to think about the wing sauce heat levels. They know them. They don't have to run back and confirm the bucket deal details. They've answered questions about it already, on their own phone, earlier in the week, when they could actually think.

That's the shift I've seen firsthand with how we run it now at Black Barrel Tavern. The week before Super Bowl, staff gets the updated menu and the game-day specials in quiz form. They take it on their phones whenever they get to it. Some of them are retaking questions during their lunch break or while they're sitting on the train. By the time they show up Sunday, the specials aren't new. The heat levels aren't a surprise. The allergen flags aren't a guessing game.

The pre-shift meeting that Sunday still matters. But it's a 15-minute recap, not a cramming session. You're reinforcing what they already know, not loading them from scratch.

Now let me tell you what the alternative looks like, because most operators are still doing it the old way. You print a cheat sheet. You go over the specials at 4pm. Half the staff is only half-listening because they're doing side work and thinking about the size of the crowd already at the bar. An hour into service, the cheat sheet is either lost or sticky with wing sauce, and your staff is improvising.

Improvising on Super Bowl Sunday is how you get a bad night. Improvising on allergens is how you get something much worse than a bad night.

The other thing worth saying: game-day specials are where your margins live. A well-built bucket deal or a shareable platter upsell can add two or three dollars of profit per table across hundreds of covers. That only works if your staff can actually sell it. Selling it confidently requires knowing it cold. If your server isn't sure whether the deal includes a second bucket at a discount or if it's only valid on domestic taps, they're going to undersell or they're going to promise something wrong. Both of those cost you money or goodwill.

Drill the specials. Drill the heat levels. Drill the allergen risks on shared platters. Drill the tap list if you brought in something seasonal for the game. Do it the week before. Do it on phones, because that's where attention lives in 2025, not in a laminated binder behind the host stand.

Super Bowl Sunday is going to be big regardless. The guests are coming. The question is whether your staff is ready or whether they're winging it, which, given what you're serving, is a bad way to spend the biggest day on your calendar.

Have a great day! — Terry Psaltakis
Your AI Restaurant Guy

For more on putting this into practice, see how ShiftTrained approaches restaurant training software.